Rohr vs. Campolo


Last week I had the pleasure of hearing to two of my favorite theologians.  One’s a spiritualist and the other’s a social activist. They couldn’t be more different. 

I went to hear on Thursday Fr. Richard Rohr at St. Philips Episcopal Cathedral.  He’s a Franciscan priest.  He spoke about living contemplatively.  On Saturday I went to First Presbyterian Church Atlanta to spend the day with Tony Campolo, a social activists and theologian from Eastern University in Philadelphia. 

I love both these guys.  But they couldn’t be more different. 

Here’s what I gathered from their lectures (I realize these next statements are polarizing and generalizations and do not represent the entire theology of either theologian but they do create enough of a dichotomy to merit this blog post): 

Rohr cares deeply about the spiritual sector.  Campolo cares deeply about the social sector.

Rohr thinks if the world would open itself to the spiritual (to awaken her mind and heart to higher forms of peace) then wars would end.  Campolo thinks wars would end when we overcome evil by sending troops home, adopting children for $38/month through Compassion International, buying mosquito nets for families suffering from malaria or building Habitat for Humanity houses for the homeless.


Rohr desires stillness.  Campolo desires a fury of activism.  Rohr wants prayer, Campolo wants change. Rohr preaches that strength rises when we wait upon the Lord.  Campolo preaches that strength rises when numbers stand up for justice and social reform.  

They both want wholeness.  But Rohr finds it in contemplation; Campolo finds it in action. 

Rohr needs God to come in the quiet, still, dark night of the soul.  Campolo needs God out on the front lines, offering food to the hungry and clothes to the naked.  Rohr meets Jesus in the garden; Campolo meets Jesus in turning over tables in the Temple. Rohr’s Jesus invites harmony.  Campolo’s Jesus invokes social reform. Rohr wants unity.  Campolo wants gospel catalysts.  

So is one better than the other?  Should we be more like Rohr or Campolo?  Should we care more about action or contemplation?  Prayer or petition?  Stillness or justice? 

And this is what I love about scripture . . . these seemingly different approaches; different perspectives, different attempts at reaching and connecting with the divine . . . are both valid.  These two ways of being aren't an either/or they’re a both/and. 

We need to be a people who listen for Spirit of the living God as well as people who stand up for peace, justice and righteousness.  We need to do both.  We must care about both. The world needs us doing both.   

This can’t be understated.  God’s love is on the move; it’s present in our waiting and in our doing.  God’s love is calling for us to respond, to give, to enjoy, to participate, to sit down together, to live within, to embrace, to follow and to dwell.  It’s calling us out of our darkness, out of our slumber, out of our small-mindedness, squabbles, frustration and deep sadness.  And when we seek this divine love, through both action and contemplation, we hear Jesus saying what he said to Nathanael in John 1:51, "Then follow me, for there are even greater things ahead.”

My prayer is that the church will become (or continue to be) a place that truly believes there are greater things ahead; and we find them through action and contemplation.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Most Difficult Parable Ever

Image
Theologian N.T. Wright finds the parable of the fig tree to be quite strange.  He says, “Jesus' warning in Luke 13 is at once amplified by this almost humorous, yet in fact quite sinister, parable of the fig tree in the vineyard.” And it is sinister.  It’s a hard pill to take.  Jesus' parable goes like this: A man has as fig tree planted in his vineyard.  One day he comes out looking for fruit on it, but there are no figs.  He says to the vineyard keeper, “Look at this tree.  For three years, I've come hoping to find some fresh figs, but what do I find? Nothing.  So just go ahead and cut it down.  Why waste the space with a fruitless tree?” The vineyard keeper replies, “Give it another chance, sir.  Give me one more years working with it.  I’ll cultivate the soil and heap on some manure to fertilize it.  If it surprises us and bears fruit next year, that will be great, but if not, then we’ll cut it down.”  (Luke 13:5-9, The Voice) But how is it sinister?
Read more

The Bird of Dawning Singeth All Night Long

Image
This Christmas I was moved by the words of Frederick Buechner.  For my last blog of the year I offer to you his wisdom rather than my own ramblings.  I hope it does for you what it continues to do for me. Frederick Buechner says in his book The Faces of Jesus: On the dark bulwark of Elsinore, Shakespeare has Marcellus and Haratio reflecting on Christ in the opening scene of Hamlet: Some say that ever ‘gainst that season comes Wherein our Savior’s birth is celebrated, The bird of dawning singeth all night long; And then, they say, no spirit dare stir abroad, The nights are wholesome, then no planets strike, No fairly takes, nor witch hath power to charm, So hallowed and so gracious is the time These lines from the first scene of Hamlet in a sense say it all.  We tend to think time is just progression . . . as moment following moment, day following day, in relentless flow, the kind of time a clock or calendar measures.  But we experience time als
Read more

All Good Things Must Come to an End

Image
In the late 1300s Geoffrey Chaucer coined the phrase, “All good things must come to an end.” This phrase means more to me right now than it ever has before. This week is my last week as pastor at Union Baptist Church in Pine Mountain, Georgia. Out of all my accomplishments, opportunities, and memories, pastoring UBC has been one of, if not, the best. For three years I have traveled alongside this community of grace through celebrations such as birthday parties, weddings, worship services, homecomings, Fall Festivals, baptisms, and so much more. I have also traveled alongside more sincere moments of pain, tragedy, and anguish; for I have counseled families through deaths, hardships, work-related problems, spirit-related inquiries, sadness, depression, anger, surgeries, confusion, and even wonderment. Collectively, these shared stories, these real and emotionally significant memories, have shaped who I am and how I see myself in the world. This decision to leave UBC do
Read more